This theater was located in the western half of a two story brick commercial building which was constructed sometime between 1890 and 1895. The location is shown as boots and shoes on the 1909 map. This portion of the building was demolished long ago, along with most of the rest of this area. The eastern half remained until 2007, and was demolished before 2015.
This theater appears on the March 1909 Sanborn. It was located in a remodeled 2 story brick commercial building which was constructed sometime before 1884. The rear of this building was extended to install the stage. The building is still on the 1951 map, but this entire block was destroyed around 1980 for a really ugly supermarket and huge parking lot.
It is not actually called that. The website calls it the Star Theatre of St. Johnsbury, and the website title implies that it may also be known as the Star 4.
That could have been either north (currently a parking lot), or south (now occupied by the A.M. Litz building from 1956). There is a 1949 update to the 1923 map, but it’s not available online.
A bit confusing. I don’t think the theater at 36-38 could have opened in 1909, since that map was issued in December, and doesn’t even show a building under construction. In addition, the New Lyric doesn’t necessarily mean there was a prior Lyric. So this was likely the Continuous, and then a New Lyric operated for about 4 years before moving to its new building, and becoming just the Lyric. Maybe.
I have rewritten the very poor initial listing, and added a Sanborn view. Although the photo in the clipping is very poor quality, it does not show the building at 219. In addition, the entry to the theater pictured is in the center, whereas the 1912 and 1921 maps both show it on the left. The Times-Mirror was definitely a Warren, PA paper, so it’s a bit confusing. It may be that the building currently at 219 is a fake of an older building (and it is 4 stories, not 3), but it appears to be higher quality than the very weak effort to the east.
The photo indicates this was open in 1977. Perhaps there was a short-lived attempt to revive it? The theater is marked as permanently closed on streetview, but the community theater group is definitely active, and their FB page shows them holding a bake sale in front of the theater during a festival this past week.
The 2015 streetview shows the building vacant. At some point afterward, the brickwork on the upper part of the facade was covered in a slovenly coat of concrete.
This may have initially been the Gem, which is listed in the 1914-15 AMPD. The building first appears on the 1924 map, while the 1912 map shows a wooden house and some sort of outbuilding on the site. Like most of the rapidly dwindling downtown, this building is very grubby, and in disrepair. It appears to have been vacant for quite a while.
I’ve added a Sanborn view to show the general plan. The brownstone entry is still there as a gate to the lot behind the rather drab replacement building.
It looks like this was indeed renumbered to 109 at some point. It may be a residence of some sort. The door is blocked, but it might be a privacy screen. Looks very shabby.
That’s definitely not a 1935 facade. I assume it got a remodel maybe 1950-60?
This theater was located in the western half of a two story brick commercial building which was constructed sometime between 1890 and 1895. The location is shown as boots and shoes on the 1909 map. This portion of the building was demolished long ago, along with most of the rest of this area. The eastern half remained until 2007, and was demolished before 2015.
This theater appears on the March 1909 Sanborn. It was located in a remodeled 2 story brick commercial building which was constructed sometime before 1884. The rear of this building was extended to install the stage. The building is still on the 1951 map, but this entire block was destroyed around 1980 for a really ugly supermarket and huge parking lot.
It is not actually called that. The website calls it the Star Theatre of St. Johnsbury, and the website title implies that it may also be known as the Star 4.
That could have been either north (currently a parking lot), or south (now occupied by the A.M. Litz building from 1956). There is a 1949 update to the 1923 map, but it’s not available online.
A bit confusing. I don’t think the theater at 36-38 could have opened in 1909, since that map was issued in December, and doesn’t even show a building under construction. In addition, the New Lyric doesn’t necessarily mean there was a prior Lyric. So this was likely the Continuous, and then a New Lyric operated for about 4 years before moving to its new building, and becoming just the Lyric. Maybe.
I’ll check the maps again, but I didn’t see any candidates for the Family or original Lyric.
Meantime, I’ve updated the listing. I think it reflects our current knowledge.
By the way, the historic address appears to have been 31, but the numbers now jump from 29 to 37.
Thanks, I’ll add it.
Thanks. I’m almost sure the Gem was the unnamed theater I added on Mahoning.
Walked right past this and didn’t take a picture for some reason. I’ve added a map view.
Theater was on the right
Joe - The Library was a smaller theater located where the Rex is today. Did it ever show movies? It’s not listed in the 1914-15 AMPD.
I’ve added a map view. I did not get a picture of this one on our recent stop in town.
There likely was a remodel in 1919, but the theater is listed in the 1914-15 AMPD.
I have rewritten the very poor initial listing, and added a Sanborn view. Although the photo in the clipping is very poor quality, it does not show the building at 219. In addition, the entry to the theater pictured is in the center, whereas the 1912 and 1921 maps both show it on the left. The Times-Mirror was definitely a Warren, PA paper, so it’s a bit confusing. It may be that the building currently at 219 is a fake of an older building (and it is 4 stories, not 3), but it appears to be higher quality than the very weak effort to the east.
The photo indicates this was open in 1977. Perhaps there was a short-lived attempt to revive it? The theater is marked as permanently closed on streetview, but the community theater group is definitely active, and their FB page shows them holding a bake sale in front of the theater during a festival this past week.
The 2015 streetview shows the building vacant. At some point afterward, the brickwork on the upper part of the facade was covered in a slovenly coat of concrete.
This may have initially been the Gem, which is listed in the 1914-15 AMPD. The building first appears on the 1924 map, while the 1912 map shows a wooden house and some sort of outbuilding on the site. Like most of the rapidly dwindling downtown, this building is very grubby, and in disrepair. It appears to have been vacant for quite a while.
I’ve updated the entry with more information, and added a map view.
I’ve added a Sanborn view to show the general plan. The brownstone entry is still there as a gate to the lot behind the rather drab replacement building.
I’ve rewritten this entry to provide more information, and corrected the address. This building does not appear on the 1906 map.
It looks like this was indeed renumbered to 109 at some point. It may be a residence of some sort. The door is blocked, but it might be a privacy screen. Looks very shabby.
DMT had added a picture of the Palace to the Novelty listing. I’ve asked that it be moved here. I’ll add the AKA.
This is the opera house. Please add this picture to that listing.